ICJ: Burma guilty of genocide against Rohingya

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) on Nov. 29 delivered a landmark judgment in The Gambia v. Myanmar: 11 States intervening, ruling that Burma (Myanmar) committed genocide against the Rohingya ethnic group in Rakhine state starting in 2017, in violation of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide.

The ICJ found that Burma violated its obligations under the Convention by failing to prevent genocide committed by individuals acting in concert with its security forces, failing to punish genocide and other prohibited acts, and failing to adopt the necessary domestic legislation to give effect to the Convention, in contravention of Article V. The ICJ further found that Burma had breached its obligation under the Court's Order of January 2020, which required Burma to prevent genocide, preserve evidence related to the violations of the Convention, follow through with regulation compliance reporting detailing its implementation of the measures, and control its security forces to prevent further injury to the Rohingya group.

Upon assessment of the evidence presented, the ICJ found Burma responsible for killing members of the Rohingya group; causing serious bodily or mental harm, including through perpetrating sexual violence; and undertaking measures to prevent births. The Court determined a set of restitution measures that Burma should implement, which include permitting the safe return of the Rohingya community to their residences; returning property belonging to the Rohingya that had been stolen or damaged as a result of Burma's wrongful acts; providing for the physical and psychological rehabilitation of the community; and aiding in search efforts to recover the bodies of community members who had lost their lives.

In November 2019, The Gambia, invoking Article IX of the 1948 Genocide Convention and Article 36(1) of the ICJ Statute submitted arguments to the ICJ stating that obligations erga omnes partes (obligations owed to a group of states, such as in multilateral treaties) gave The Gambia locus standi (legal standing) to bring a case against Burma over violations of the Genocide Convention, despite not suffering direct injury. Although the ICJ Statute does not explicitly use the term locus standi, jurisprudence developed amid the Court's work has recognized several ways in which a state may establish legally protected interest in a claim.

These include having suffered direct injury, obligations erga omnes (obligations owed to the international community as a whole), treaty clauses, and obligations erga omnes partes, the latter of which The Gambia had asserted in its 2019 case filing. In 2022, the ICJ rejected preliminary objections filed by Burma to the jurisdiction of the Court, affirming that it was a "common interest" of signatories to the Convention to prevent and punish genocide. In 2023, several Member States to the Convention—Canada, Denmark, France, Germany, the Netherlands and the UK—filed a joint declaration to intervene, citing a "common interest in the accomplishment of the high purposes of the Genocide Convention." These interventions were later deemed admissible by the ICJ in a 2024 ruling.

In November 2024, Slovenia also filed a declaration of intervention, citing "its experience as a former Yugoslav republic in a region scarred by the Srebrenica genocide," followed by the Democratic Republic of Congo, Belgium and Ireland in December 2024.

Yousuf Ali, a Rohingya survivor and member of the victims' delegation present at the hearings, hailed the ruling, stating: "Today, we have finally been heard, and it is a profound relief. This judgment gives hope to our children and the next generation of Rohingya. But our fight is not over. We need our rights, our citizenship, reparations, and the chance to return home safely and with dignity."

From JURIST, Nov. 19. Used with permission.

Note: This report originally used the country's new rendering of Myanmar. We changed it to Burma in conformity with our style, which we explain here.

See our last report on the Rohingya.